
What is the importance of hull design?
What are the Qualities and Concepts of Power Catamarans?
What are some of the definitions used in the Power
Catamaran industry?
Can you explain Catamaran hull design theories?
Why is weight so important?
Why do Twin Vee's 19 and 17 footers utilize a single
engine?
What is the best coring material?
Isn't
all this "state of the art" expensive?
WHAT IS THE IMPORTANCE
OF HULL DESIGN?
There is a huge secret in the boat building industry-Whether
your boat is a small one or a large one, there is nothing
else that will make as much difference in your boating
pleasure as the design of your hull. And nothing else
can make it go faster or perform better.
This may come as a surprise to many boat buyers who
are used to owning cars of every type without having
the exterior conditions actually affect their
driving pleasure. However boat exterior conditions change constantly and
widely depending on wind , tides, and current.
At Twin Vee, hull design is central to the design
philosophy of Roger Dunshee, founder of Twin Vee and
one of
the best small boat hull designers in the world
today. The planing catamaran hull was picked because it offered the most
complete package of benefits over V-hull designs currently
popular. The advantages of
a softer and dryer ride in heavy seas and chop was very important. Efficiency,
stability and safety advantages over V-hull designs made the design choice
easier. Twin Vee developed a super strong hull and because of it's design
prowess in weight and balance, was able to create these
features in a cat that was
also fast. The result today is the best line of small boats on the market
. These cats have the ocean going capability of V-hulls
25-30% larger. The ability
to go through 4-5 feet chop at high speeds , comfortably, and safely, is
a singular accomplishment in the boating industry.
The dedication of Twin Vee to hull designs is the
reason that Twin Vee has developed strong customer
loyalty
and proven performance from Bermuda to Kona
in the world's biggest waters. An additional benefit that came with the package
is that cats have a shallow draft. Twin Vee Cats have drafts from7"(17ft),
8-10"(20ft), to 12"(22ft). This allows Twin Vee to perform very successfully
in the shallow waters and flats of Florida , Texas, the Bahamas, Cape Cod and
bays everywhere.
Additional work was done on the hull design to allow
for single engine performance in Twin Vee cats
20 feet and lower. This was a significant accomplishment
that
has since become the industry standard.
Hull design is central to performance, comfort and
speed among other things. But how can a potential
buyer test the hull design? The answer is a test
ride in different sea or chop conditions. The average sea state in the
Atlantic
is about 3 feet- higher from November to April. The average wind speed
is about
10-11 knots, again higher in the winter (in Florida). If the buyer wanted
to be able to go boating year round, then a test in 3-5 ft seas or wind
speeds of around 15 knots or more would be called
for. Any place where such conditions
could be duplicated would suffice for test purposes. In any case , a
test ride
in calm, protected waters is inadequate.
Additionally, in the case of twin engines, it is
important to test the planing ability of a boat with
one engine off and tilted up. This test
simulates
an engine failure off shore. Over 90% of V-hulls will fail this test,
even with
large engines, due to the inefficiency of the hull. By comparison, a
20 foot Twin Vee can plane with a single 50hp motor
and a 22 can plane with
a single
70hp. The failure of a single engine to plane a boat is a safety issue.
The boating buying public has been kept in the dark about the importance
of hull design. Twin Vee is a manufacturer that can be trusted to fully
understand the issues surrounding hull performance and testing. It is
proud of its pioneering
development of the best small boat hulls in the world today. Its customers
can have the most enjoyable boating experience at a most affordable price.
WHAT ARE THE QUALITIES AND CONCEPTS OF POWER CATAMARANS?
It seems new catamarans are entering the world of
power boating every day. Numerous magazines have featured "cats" on
their front page. What is making these boats so popular?
By now, many know their qualities: soft ride, performance,
comfort, and stability. Those fortunate enough to have
experienced "the cat ride" swear they cannot
go back to V-hulls.
We like to introduce boaters to "the cat ride." The recipe is easy
but you've got to pick the weather! Sunny is nice, but not for demonstrating
Twin Vee Cats. Make sure the wind is blowing at least 15 mph, then make your
way to the inlet. Now you have the perfect mess that most boats (and boater's
backs) loathe. Ahead, a 5' chop with plenty of white caps approaches and the
cat smoothly slices the wave and moves up on the next one. The green face turns
toward you with a surprised grin. "How in the heck...???" Makes a
Twin Vee dealer's day every time.
Truly there is no bad cat in terms of ride, and even an average catamaran will
compare favorably to a V-hull boat of the same size. However, to move a cat
from average to great requires a special touch. If we've learned anything from
seven years of testing multihulls, it is the great importance of reducing weight
and creating balance to create great performance, comfort, SAFETY.
Today, we
have over 7 years of R&D on our 6 Hulls.
It is this R&D investment
that has allowed Twin Vee to be the technological leader in developing the
most affordable ,soft riding , fast and safe power catamarans on the market
today.
WHAT ARE SOME OF THE DEFINITIONS USED IN THE POWER
CATAMARAN INDUSTRY?
Tunnel
All cats have one, although some are specifically called the tunnel hull. It's
the space between the two hulls and the underwing or bridge deck, and is relied
upon for lift.
Slamming (Called "pounding" on V-hulls)
Occurs when a wave is trapped inside the tunnel and hits the underwing. Lightweight,
good design, and sustained speed prevent slamming.
Sneezing
Exclusive to cats, it's a spray from the front of the tunnel back into the
boat. Air compresses the water and creates a cushion. The air cannot escape
out the back of the tunnel and thus is forced forward. Poor design and /or
balance usually cause sneezing, and weight can sometimes be a factor. Thanks
to our great hull design and attention to weight and balance, Twin Vee PowerCats
are practically immune to sneezing.
Banking ("Leaning" for some)
The lateral attitude of a vessel, applicable to moving vehicles as well. V-hulls,
bicycles, and motorcycles bank into a turn. Power catamarans, on the other
hand, are more similar to cars. They tend to bank out of the turn and it
takes a little getting used to! If you think of your car as riding a bus
standing up, it's the same idea.
CAN YOU EXPLAIN THE CATAMARAN HULL DESIGN THEORIES?
There are three types of hull design for catamarans.
Each design relies on the tunnel effect to some degree,
and each can have innumerable variations within its
type.
Tunnel Hulls
As the name implies, these boats rely on lift to operate from the bottom hull
when compressing air into the tunnel. As you can imagine, this can only happen
at high speeds, and this means that a lot of power is needed to bring the
boat up to plane. A tunnel hull performs poorly at lower or trawling speed.
Also, due to their mostly flat-paneled bottoms, the ride can be rough in
waves.
Displacement Hulls
Displacement hulls depend on buoyancy. The volume of the hulls is a major contributing
factor- the boat slices waves instead of punching them, and it does not come
up on a plane. This accounts for the smooth ride. Some factors such as friction
from the wetted area can limit the top speed and can also cause both slamming
and sneezing.
Planning Hulls
These are hybrid hulls combing features of both tunnel and displacement hulls.
They provide a smooth ride and top speed for less overhead. Twin Vee's proprietary
asymmetrical bottoms do just that, plus control the amount and flow of water
in the tunnel that the center propulsion requires.
WHY IS WEIGHT SO IMPORTANT?
Catamaran hull shape by nature is easily driven through
the water. It requires less power to attain the same
speed as a V-hull. The largest single negative is weight
and its location. It will impact comfort and safety
since a heavy cat is low in the water. It will then
suffer from underwing slamming, sneezing and slow steering
reactions. A heavy cat also needs more power and more
fuel (also more weight). The Domino effect is hard
to stop. And since we are talking trailerables, the
heavy cat will also need a heavier trailer and a bigger
vehicle to tow the whole package!
WHY DO TWIN VEE'S 20 AND 17 FOOTERS UTILIZE A SINGLE
ENGINE?
Because they can! The real answer is multi layered
and will depend on how you intend to use the boat.
A day trip within 5 miles of land does not call for
twins. A Florida/Bahamas crossing, Channel Islands,
Catalina or Dry Tortuga trip will usually call for
a twin setup. Single engine catamarans are asked for
and we made it work where others have failed.
WHAT IS THE BEST CORING MATERIAL?
In many respects, wood is actually stronger than any material known-even so called
space age material. What's more, wood is far less expensive.
How can wood be stronger than Kevlar and graphite fibers? It is stronger-
strange as it seems. The answer lies in understanding "strength." There are
two critical types of strength: tensile and stiffness (the modulus of elasticity,
or Young's modulus-E). Both are measured in pounds per square inch (psi). Following
is a comparison of space age materials in order of "strongest" to "weakest."
Strengths
of Materials
|
tensile strength |
stiffness or E |
weight |
|
psi |
psi |
lb./cu.ft |
| Graphite |
170,000 |
12,900,000 |
100 |
| Spectra |
168,000 |
9,400,000 |
82 |
| Titanium |
150,000 |
17,500,000 |
140 |
| S-glass |
128,000 |
5,500,000 |
95 |
| Kevlar |
90,000 |
3,200,000 |
80 |
| Steel |
60,000 |
30,000,000 |
495 |
| Aluminum |
40,000 |
10,400,000 |
168 |
| E-glass |
15,000 |
1,400,000 |
95 |
| Douglas
fir |
12,400 |
1,950,000 |
32 |
It doesn't appear that wood is very strong in the
above chart. But boats and most structures require
the minimum weight for a given strength. So we must
compare strength relative to weight by dividing the
strength or stiffness by density, giving us the next
two charts.
Tensile Strength vs. Weight
|
psi/lb./cu.ft |
| Spectra |
2,049 |
| Graphite |
1,700 |
| S-glass |
1,347 |
| Kevlar |
1,125 |
| Titanium |
1,071 |
| Douglas fir |
388 |
| Aluminum |
238 |
| E-glass |
158 |
| Steel |
121 |
Stiffness vs. Weight
|
psi/lb./cu.ft |
| Graphite |
129,000 |
| Titanium |
125,000 |
| Spectra |
114,000 |
| Aluminum |
61,905 |
| Douglas fir |
60,938 |
| Steel |
60,606 |
| S-glass |
57,895 |
| Kevla |
40,000 |
| E-glass |
14,737 |
Wood has moved up in both charts, but is still behind.
But because stiffness is more important in most structures
including boats, the structural efficiency must be
measured. Here wood wins.
Structural Efficiency Relative to Weight:
Columns
|
Square root of
psi |
|
lb./cu.ft. |
| Douglas fir |
44 |
| Spectra |
37 |
| Graphite |
36 |
| Titanium |
30 |
| S-glass |
25 |
| Kevlar |
22 |
| Aluminum |
19 |
| E-glass |
12 |
| Steel |
11 |
Structural Efficiency Relative to Weight: Beams and
Panels
|
Square root of
psi |
|
lb./cu.ft |
| Douglas Fir |
3.91 |
| Spectra |
2.58 |
| Graphite |
2.38 |
| S-glass |
1.86 |
| Titanium |
1.86 |
| Kevlar |
1.84 |
| Aluminum |
1.30 |
| E-glass |
1.18 |
| Steel |
0.63 |
Amazingly- and contrary to everything you've probably
read and heard-wood is structurally far more efficient
than any of the building materials known
anywhere. In other words, you can build a lighter structure out of wood than
of anything else, for the same stiffness.
In addition wood has better durability under compressive
loads and better resistance to degradation over time
than "composites." The major exception is
that untreated or unprotected wood can and will rot if exposed to water over
an extended period of time. Twin Vee coring material is protected completely
and the core is treated and given a lifetime warranty by the manufacturer.
Twin Vee has command of whatever material and methods it uses and stands behind
its products.
ISN'T ALL THIS "STATE OF ART" EXPENSIVE?
No, Twin Vee's design philosophy is affordable power
catamarans. If you want performance, strength, comfort,
economy, dependability, durability, low maintenance
and resale all in one package, then isn't it nice that
it is also affordable.
|